For the families living near South Africa’s coal-fired power stations, the air they breathe has long carried a deadly cost. Pollution from coal plants kills more than 2,200 South African residents every year, according to the Centre for Environmental Rights, and causes thousands of cases of bronchitis and asthma. It was on behalf of those communities, and the children growing up in their shadow, that a coalition of environmental organizations took the government to court. Their case has now scored a decisive victory.
The Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa has dismissed the government’s appeal against a ruling that struck down plans to build 1,500 MW of new coal-fired generation capacity. The High Court’s verdict against those plans therefore remains in force.
The case, known as #CancelCoal, rested on a simple constitutional argument: the plaintiffs contended that adding new coal capacity would violate children’s right to an environment that is not harmful to their health and well-being. The Centre for Environmental Rights, which represented the coalition throughout the proceedings, pointed to coal pollution’s human toll as evidence of what is at stake.
The government had defended the plans on practical grounds. South Africa’s Minister of Electricity and Energy argued that the additional coal capacity was needed to ensure energy security. The High Court, however, found that the plan violated the constitutional right to a healthy environment, and the appeals court has now let that finding stand.
Michelle Sitoe, a senior attorney in the Centre for Environmental Rights’ Pollution and Climate Change Programme, explained that the court did not accept the government’s arguments about power grid stability as sufficient justification for overriding constitutional rights. In her view, the ruling does not spell the final end of new coal-fired generation in South Africa. It does mean the government must now offer a more convincing justification if it wants to choose coal for the country’s electricity.
The legal story may not be over. The Minister of Electricity and Energy can still appeal the Supreme Court of Appeal’s decision to South Africa’s Constitutional Court. For now, though, the 1,500 MW of planned coal capacity remains struck down, and the communities who brought the case can point to a ruling that puts their health, and their children’s, at the center of the country’s energy debate. Whether that victory holds will depend on what the courts say next.