South Africa’s economy is expanding at only 1% to 2% a year, and a new report from the Institute of Race Relations (IRR) puts the blame squarely on capital. The country’s growth problem is, at its core, an investment problem, the report argues: a persistent failure to attract and retain the capital needed to drive growth, create jobs and raise living standards. At those growth rates, the economy offers no game-changing answer to mass unemployment or the scale of poverty.
Titled “Open(ing) for business”: South Africa’s investment malaise and how to escape it, the report was written by IRR analyst Terence Corrigan and will be launched at a webinar on 24 November. The numbers are stark. The National Development Plan envisaged investment reaching 30% of GDP. The current figure sits at around 15%. South Africa also trails its middle-income peers globally, which routinely achieve investment rates well above 30%.
Additional reference context is available at https://irr.org.za/media/new-irr-report-examines-sas-investment-malaise-2013-and-what-can-be-done-to-reverse-it-1.
For investors and market watchers, the report’s diagnosis of why capital is staying away will carry particular weight. It examines the policy choices and institutional weaknesses behind the shortfall: an expanding regulatory burden, restrictive labour legislation, employment equity and B-BBEE requirements, uncertainty around property rights, corruption, and the deterioration of state capacity. Crime, organised extortion and failing infrastructure have piled further costs and risks onto businesses operating in the country.
By contrast, the report’s argument extends beyond foreign capital. South African firms themselves are failing to invest in their own country, and restoring their confidence, it contends, is essential to changing the economic trajectory. Domestic capital, in other words, is as decisive a test of the operating environment as foreign appetite.
The report also sets out practical remedies, delving into the crime crisis, infrastructure, the regulatory burden on business, state dysfunction, corruption and misplaced policy. Local government receives particular attention. Municipal dysfunction, the report argues, is not merely a service-delivery problem; it directly undermines the conditions in which businesses operate and investment takes place.
The launch webinar takes place on Tuesday, 24 November at 10:00. Corrigan, IRR Projects and Publications Manager, will be joined by Anlu Keeve, IRR Economic Policy Analyst and Research Coordinator, in discussing the findings. Media enquiries can be directed to Terence Corrigan on 066 470 4456 or at [email protected], or to Michael Morris on 066 302 1968 or at [email protected].
Until investment levels move decisively toward the 30% target, growth will stay too weak to shift the unemployment and poverty picture, and the conditions businesses need to commit capital will remain in question. Whether South Africa can close that gap is the question the report leaves on the table.