The contest over who leads the City of Johannesburg has become a test of how institutions, and the media that cover them, handle the democratic consequences of the ballot. Writing in a guest contribution published on 21 November 2026, Sinawo Thambo, the Economic Freedom Fighters’ spokesperson, argues that South Africa is a constitutional democracy rather than a private estate belonging to the Democratic Alliance, and that no party holds a divine right to govern. His intervention, framed as media criticism, raises accountability questions that extend well beyond one city’s council chambers.
The legal framework at the centre of the argument is straightforward. Where no party secures a majority in a municipal council, the law provides for representatives to elect leadership and establish governing arrangements. Thambo contends that the DA, despite receiving the largest share of votes in a municipality, cannot claim a mandate from a share of approximately 35 percent, since the largest share is not a majority. A party, he argues, cannot demand respect for the ballot box while refusing to respect the democratic consequences of that same ballot box.
Additional reference context is available at https://www.ewn.co.za/2026/11/21/sinawo-thambo-media-must-accept-that-south-africa-s-democracy-will-work-with-or-without-the-da.
Meanwhile, the core of his critique is directed at editorial judgment rather than at any single negotiation. He describes media coverage as increasingly portraying the exclusion of the DA from municipal governments as a threat to democracy, economic stability and the country’s future, while treating every coalition involving the ANC, EFF, MK and other parties as illegitimate and every arrangement that does not favour the DA as a disaster in the making. In his words, this is political campaigning dressed up as analysis. The responsibility of the press, as he frames it, is to educate society about coalition politics, explain electoral outcomes and hold all political parties accountable, not to manufacture a national crisis each time the DA fails to secure power.
The argument also touches on the use of economic indicators in political reporting. Thambo criticises reporting that links the weakening of the rand and threats to economic stability to coalition arrangements that do not favour the DA. Currency movements, he writes, are influenced by international markets, interest rates, investor sentiment and domestic conditions, among other factors. Coalition uncertainty may be one consideration, but it cannot serve as a convenient explanation for every economic difficulty. The performance of municipalities, he adds, must be judged on budgets, infrastructure and service delivery rather than on predictions designed to frighten residents into accepting one party as their only option.
A second, structural argument concerns proposals for devolution and the fragmentation of metropolitan areas. Thambo calls for the DA’s advocacy of greater devolution to be interrogated where it risks becoming a mechanism through which wealthy communities separate themselves from broader social and economic responsibilities. Proposals to break Gauteng’s metropolitan areas into smaller, locality-based cities, he writes, must be examined against the reality of apartheid spatial planning, in which some communities accumulated wealth, infrastructure and property values through generations of privilege while others live with the consequences of forced removals, land dispossession and deliberate underdevelopment. Fragmenting cities without confronting those inequalities, he warns, risks creating new enclaves of privilege while leaving poorer communities with weaker revenue bases. He points to the convergence of arguments advanced by the DA, Afriforum and sections of the right-wing political establishment around separation, resistance to transformation and the protection of historically advantaged interests, describing the underlying instinct as an old apartheid logic expressed through contemporary language.
On the EFF’s own position, Thambo argues that the party’s participation in coalitions is constitutionally legitimate and points to its litigation record, including the Nkandla litigation, which affirmed the binding nature of the Public Protector’s remedial action and the accountability of the President, as well as constitutional litigation concerning Phala Phala and a court challenge to the VAT increase. Its conduct in government, he concedes, must be judged on evidence like that of any other party, with corruption investigated and maladministration exposed, but its presence in office cannot itself be treated as misconduct. He characterises such framing as a contemporary Swart Gevaar narrative.
The closing demands are directed at editors and politicians alike. Editors must report on coalition politics without becoming participants in those negotiations and must interrogate the DA with the same intensity reserved for the ANC, EFF and MK. The DA, for its part, must accept that it can lose negotiations. South Africa’s institutions, Thambo concludes, will continue to function and its democracy will continue to mature with or without the DA in government, and the media must report that reality rather than campaign against it. Whether editors and parties act on that demand remains the open question his intervention leaves behind.